Today there are many tools, gadgets and accessories that, while increasing your comfort or efficiency, are not essential to a safe and successful trip into the woods.
A good knife is not one of them.
Ask any hunter, explorer, survivalist, wildlife explorer, or anyone spending extended periods outdoors: A reliable blade is a necessity. Our earliest ancestors figured this out long ago, and it’s been held to be true ever since. Wherever demand goes, supply naturally follows, meaning today’s market is flooded with tons of brands, designs and features.
We’re gonna keep it simple. Benchmade is our go-to brand. This California-born, Oregon-based company has been slinging blades since 1980, when it started out as a two-man show. Founder Les de Asis specialized in a type of butterfly knife from the Philippines known as balisong. (Before Benchmade was Benchmade, the company was actually called Bali-Song, Inc.)
In 1987, the company renamed Benchmade, moved to Clackamas, Oregon, and became the first knife company to use a high-performance laser cutter, which meant they could make knives from stronger steels than ever before. They moved to their current manufacturing center in Oregon City in 1990 and grew into the company we know them as today.
Jump to: The hunting knives we use
What we look for in a hunting knife
When it comes to hunting knives, you want to reach for something precise enough for making that first cut on an animal while it’s still warm, but also for varied tasks like quartering, severing tough tendons, and even trimming fillets or slicing open Heart the pan back in storage. This one knife has got to be the master of all alleys, tough as hell and lighter than a breath when it comes to adding weight to your gear. With this in mind we are looking for:
- Size Versatility
- robustness
- packability
Jump to: What makes a good hunting knife
The hunting knives we use
![]() Benchmade Essential MeatCrafter Steve’s choice |
![]() Benchmade hidden canyon Mark’s choice |
![]() Benchmade Steep Country The choice of Janis and Clay |
|
---|---|---|---|
blade length |
6.08 inches |
2.79 inches |
3.54 inches |
open length |
11.06 inches |
6.42 inches |
7.76 inches |
weight |
3.24 oz |
3.11 oz |
3.0 oz |
blade steel |
CPM-154 (58-61HRC) |
CPM-S90V (59-61 HRC) |
CPM-S30V (58-60HRC) |
Price |
$139.99* |
$199.99* |
$114.99* |
field notes |
field notes |
field notes |
*Price in the MeatEater Store on 8/1/22
What makes a good hunting knife
1. Size Variety
Let’s face it… if we could carry a block full of knives on a backcountry slog, we probably would. What would a hunting knife set look like? Maybe one for small incisions, one for long cuts, one for working around intricate joints, and one for cleaning under our fingernails after the job is done. (If you say you’ve never done this, in a rare moment of outdoor boredom, you’re lying.)
But to avoid looking like Atlas carrying the globe across creeks and creeks, grab a light backpack and stick to a do-it-all leaf. Hidden Canyon and Steep Country both feature a drop point blade, widely considered one of the best shapes for skinning game. Because the tip descends from the back of the blade, you’re less likely to accidentally cut open organs while making long cuts through skin.
The trailing tip of the Meatcrafter is also great for super precise cuts. This is the narrowest blade of the three from top to bottom, allowing it to navigate nooks and crannies with ease.
2. Robustness
We’ll get to steel hardness values below, but for now all you need to know is that the steel Benchmade uses for these three knives is the perfect combination of toughness and flexibility. They can withstand any wear and tear we subject them to, but they’re not so tough that brittleness becomes an issue. Sharpening is a breeze, especially with a tool like the Work Sharp Field Sharpener.
3. Packability
Knives can quickly become heavy and in the way. These benchmade knives all feature a sleek, ultra-lightweight design that will make you forget you’re even carrying them. Each adds about 3 ounces to your kit, meaning they’ll pull their weight and then some.
The orange handles and sheath are designed to stand out in your backpack when you don’t want to carry your knife on your belt. Even the Hidden Canyon’s wood grain handle features a striking blaze contour. If you’re worried about sticking your hand in your backpack and catching the tip of a blade exposed by a loose sheath, don’t worry. These sheaths are designed to fit the blade and handle perfectly and won’t slip off no matter how hard you shove your gear around.
How hard is this steel anyway?
There are a number of different systems for rating steel hardness, but we’ll stick with the Rockwell scale, which is the most common measure of cutlery. Steel hardness is measured in HRC, which stands for “Rockwell Cone Hardness”. Testers load a small diamond cone at a 120 degree angle and see how much pressure the metal can withstand before indenting.
The general range is between 52 HRC and 68 HRC. These three knives fall in the range of around 58 HRC to 61 HRC, which is the ideal point for robustness and flexibility. Anything lower and you start flirting with weakness, anything higher and you threaten to snap off the top with a heavy punch. This is the most common HRC range for high quality pocket knives.
Field notes from the MeatEater crew
Steve’s choice
Benchmade MeatCrafter
Price: $139.99
“If I could only have one hunting and fishing knife for the rest of my life, it would be the original MeatCrafter that I designed with Benchmade.”
Steve’s knives have to work just as hard as he does, so it’s no wonder he chose the ones he helped design. “I butcher and fillet just about anything that goes through my kitchen with this thing,” Steve said. “No wonder people are reselling this knife on eBay for three times its original value.”
While you can no longer get Steve’s exact favorite knife, Benchmade has created two similar knives based on the design of the original MeatCrafter. The specs and price we provide here are for the Essential MeatCrafter, but if you’re looking for a premium option you’ll love the MeatCrafter 2.0, which shares many characteristics with the original model.
specifications
- blade length: 6.08 inches
- Open length: 11.06 inches
- Weight: 3.24 oz
- blade steel: CPM-154 (58-61HRC)
- Price: $139.99 at the MeatEater Store
Mark’s choice
Benchmade hidden canyon
Price: $199.99
“When I’m out hunting, I always have this light blade with me.”
On long trips into the Whitetail Woods, Mark tries to lighten his load as much as possible, and his pickaxe helps him. “My favorite hunting knife is the Benchmade Hidden Canyon,” said Mark. “It’s sharp as hell, sturdier than an ox, and about as compact as you can get in a full-tang drop-point blade.”
specifications
- blade length: 2.79 inches
- Open length: 6.42 inches
- Weight: 3.11 oz
- blade steel: CPM-S90V (59-61HRC)
- Price: $199.99 at the MeatEater Store
The choice of Janis and Clay

Benchmade Steep Country
Price: $114.99
“It’s small enough to be lightweight but large enough to securely fill my hand.”
“I like a sheath knife because I don’t lose it easily.”
With the variety of hunts that Janis undertakes, a versatile knife is crucial. “I have a fondness for benchmade steep country. It’s small enough to process a rabbit and big enough to skin and gut a moose,” said Janis. “It also has a high-visibility orange handle, which is made of a sticky, rubberized substance for a good grip. Last but not least, it can really be sharpened by you; with the right sharpener, you’ll never be without a sharp blade.”
The Steep Country’s versatility also lends itself to all clay skinning needs. “I love the Benchmade Steep Country knife,” Clay said. “It’s just the right size for serious skinning of big or small game. It sharpens quickly and the blade shape makes it a great utility knife.”
specifications
- blade length: 3.54 inches
- Open length: 7.76 inches
- Weight: 3.0 oz
- blade steel: CPM-S30V (58-60HRC)
- Price: $114.99 at the MeatEater Store